On April 1st a new roommate moved into one of the four bedrooms in our apartment. After he was moved in, some things were learned that made some of the initial three roommates uncomfortable living with the new person. After some discussions and other things...us three initial roommates offered the new guy some cash if he would agree to get out by the first of May. He agreed, took the cash offered, and signed a document drawn up by a lawyer saying he agreed to vacate and that all of us release the others from any and all liability. (ie: We own him nothing and he owes us nothing.)
Since he was leaving on short notice, he didn't have time to move his bed out of the apartment. I verbally said that he could keep it there until the weekend. I asked him to tell me a firm date when he would have it out. He said he'd move it on Saturday May 5th and "by Sunday at the latest." I sent texts, emails, and left voice-mails a number of times on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday asking if he was coming to get the bed so that one of us could be there to let him in (he had returned his keys.) He did not reply at all.
On Monday the 7th, a new roommate moved in to take his room. I had to move his bed out of his old room. I made space for it in my already cramped room. I posted the bed for-sale on Craig's List. I'm hoping to recoup some of the money I had to pay to get him out and for the lawyer to draw up documents. There is a person coming today to look at the bed.
But, of course, today I get an email from the ex-roommate, "I am sorry, I have been very sick and haven't worked or been able to get out. I will check on this and get back to you ASAP." Do I just say, "Sorry. Too Late." Or, since we were the ones asking him to leave and since he may have been sick, do I give him another chance to get his bed?
Need Opinion -- What Would Boardies Do (WWBD) ??
Started by
Jabadoodle
, May 09 2012 05:10 PM
48 replies to this topic
#5
-
- VibeTribe
- 10,590 posts
Posted 09 May 2012 - 05:14 PM
You called him several times.
He could have shown the common courtesy of calling you back. Being "sick" isn't an excuse for that except for extreme illness.
I'd be honest. I'd say there's someone coming to look at purchasing the bed today and if he wants to keep the bed, he better arrive before the potential buyer does.
He could have shown the common courtesy of calling you back. Being "sick" isn't an excuse for that except for extreme illness.
I'd be honest. I'd say there's someone coming to look at purchasing the bed today and if he wants to keep the bed, he better arrive before the potential buyer does.
#6
-
- VibeTribe
- 10,590 posts
Posted 09 May 2012 - 05:16 PM
ok
Looks like I'm the dick in the thread.
It just sounds to me like Jaba made a very reasonable effort and his ex-roommate is a bit of a deadbeat he probably needs a firm ultimatum to get motivated. He already was given one ultimatum. What's to say he doesn't blow off a second one?
Looks like I'm the dick in the thread.
It just sounds to me like Jaba made a very reasonable effort and his ex-roommate is a bit of a deadbeat he probably needs a firm ultimatum to get motivated. He already was given one ultimatum. What's to say he doesn't blow off a second one?
#7
-
- VibeTribe
- 6,357 posts
Posted 09 May 2012 - 05:17 PM
if it were me i'd reply, "sorry man, i already sold it. had to get it out before the new roomate moved in & i contacted you numerous times w/ no response so i figured you ditched it".
if you give him another chance, he may just end up screwing you again. get whatever money you can for it & forget it. he couldn't return a text? i find that a little ridiculous.
if you give him another chance, he may just end up screwing you again. get whatever money you can for it & forget it. he couldn't return a text? i find that a little ridiculous.
#10
-
- VibeTribe
- 6,357 posts
Posted 09 May 2012 - 05:19 PM
ok Looks like I'm the dick in the thread.
it looks like i may be the bigger dick here
& i agree
#11
-
- VibeTribe
- 5,287 posts
- LocationNutmeg State
Posted 09 May 2012 - 05:20 PM
sounds like it's a good thing that the only problem remaining is a bed... I wonder what he's sleeping on.... but anyway I'd say at most give him one more chance, and let him know that you have to get rid of it if he doesn't send someone to get it or get it himself 
#13
-
- VibeTribe
- 16,873 posts
Posted 09 May 2012 - 05:21 PM
If the guy has been sick and unable to leave, to me, that indicates he doesn't need the bed. No returned calls, broken oral contract. I would probably work it the same way brahhnold DHS said. Tell him a buyer is coming to look at it and he has between now and then to retreive it or it's history.
Seems more than reasonable. Even for a libertarian like me.
Seems more than reasonable. Even for a libertarian like me.
#14
-
- VibeTribe
- 2,087 posts
He saw the spinning lights he knew it was a sign....
Posted 09 May 2012 - 05:23 PM
I had a situation somewhat similar where an expected roommate moved a bunch of stuff in, then never showed up to live there. Tried contacting the person for a month. Kept her stuff for two months, then sold what I could to pay for the rent she never paid, and threw away the rest.
She then showed up at my door five months after looking for her stuff. I tried not to laugh in her face....
Anyway, this person has made a valid attempt to contact you, and five days is not really a reasonable time to not give the persons stuff back...
She then showed up at my door five months after looking for her stuff. I tried not to laugh in her face....
Anyway, this person has made a valid attempt to contact you, and five days is not really a reasonable time to not give the persons stuff back...
#18
-
- VibeTribe
- 3,684 posts
- LocationBoston MA
Posted 09 May 2012 - 05:25 PM
One other data-point: Once he decided to take the cash and split, he asked if I knew of anyone that would want to buy the bed -- said he would take $300 for it. That leads me to believe he doesn't need it to sleep on.
Thanks for the replies. Interesting that their is a mix -- same mix that is in my head.
Thanks for the replies. Interesting that their is a mix -- same mix that is in my head.
#25
-
- VibeTribe
- 12,075 posts
Posted 09 May 2012 - 05:49 PM
i don't know what he did in the past to make him an unsuitable roommate (not curious either - it's none of my business) but to avoid any unpleasantness i would give him 'til the weekend to get it out with the caveat that you will sell it if it's not gone on Saturday by a certain time.
i'd be tempted to sell it back to him for the price it cost you to get him out...but it seems like that was money well spent, so personally i'd forgo that and just be glad he's out of the picture completely. it's best to avoid making enemies when you can, IMO.
i'd be tempted to sell it back to him for the price it cost you to get him out...but it seems like that was money well spent, so personally i'd forgo that and just be glad he's out of the picture completely. it's best to avoid making enemies when you can, IMO.
#28
-
- VibeTribe
- 8,284 posts
- LocationWhisky a Go Go
Posted 09 May 2012 - 06:09 PM
keep the frame, ditch the mattress.
there's a lot of unknowns here like the size and value of the bed as well as the reason you booted him off the island.
Did you kick him out because he shoots dope? Does he have AIDS? If it's any of those than I'm sure he's sick.
Do you suspect him of stealing? Did he steal your girlfriend? I don't know... lots of factors.
there's a lot of unknowns here like the size and value of the bed as well as the reason you booted him off the island.
Did you kick him out because he shoots dope? Does he have AIDS? If it's any of those than I'm sure he's sick.
Do you suspect him of stealing? Did he steal your girlfriend? I don't know... lots of factors.
#36
-
- VibeTribe
- 24,028 posts
Posted 09 May 2012 - 06:47 PM
You called him several times. He could have shown the common courtesy of calling you back. Being "sick" isn't an excuse for that except for extreme illness.
Seriously!! He could have had someone call on his behalf if he was too sick to pick up his phone to call or text you back!
#42
-
- VibeTribe
- 4,023 posts
Posted 09 May 2012 - 07:55 PM
blech. a used bed is one thing i would never ever want to buy. id rather (and have) sleep on the floor than a used bed off CL.
that said i think id need to know more about the original problem to say... if he really was causing a problem like he lied about the fact that he is a die hard racist, sexist and homeophobe and thats why you wanted him out... something like that then screw him. but if it was bc you and your roomies decided you didnt like to hear him singing operettas or something then i say give the poor bastard his bed back.
that said i think id need to know more about the original problem to say... if he really was causing a problem like he lied about the fact that he is a die hard racist, sexist and homeophobe and thats why you wanted him out... something like that then screw him. but if it was bc you and your roomies decided you didnt like to hear him singing operettas or something then i say give the poor bastard his bed back.
#48
-
- VibeTribe
- 1,083 posts
Posted 09 May 2012 - 10:18 PM
Seriously, who's too *sick* to quickly send a text asking for a bit more time, because they are *sick?*
I mean, even after throwing up or whatever, your fingers will still work.
You tried to give him ample notice. He finally did respond, but really, grow up.
I'd tell him, OK, I'm keeping it until _ date, then it's out.
Really. Some people need to get it together. It's not like he left behind a few shirts, this is a big piece of furniture...he just can't think someone's going t keep it laying around for him.
I mean, even after throwing up or whatever, your fingers will still work.
You tried to give him ample notice. He finally did respond, but really, grow up.
I'd tell him, OK, I'm keeping it until _ date, then it's out.
Really. Some people need to get it together. It's not like he left behind a few shirts, this is a big piece of furniture...he just can't think someone's going t keep it laying around for him.
